Citizens Depopulation and Takeout Offers in 2026: What a Miami Homeowner Should Know

Last updated: July 2026

If you hold a Citizens policy on a Miami property, a depopulation takeout offer is not junk mail, and it is not optional in the way most owners assume. Under Florida law, if an authorized private insurer offers comparable coverage at a premium that is not more than 20 percent greater than your Citizens renewal premium, the risk is no longer eligible for Citizens coverage [1][2]. You still choose among the private offers. You just cannot choose to stay. If every offer comes in more than 20 percent above the Citizens renewal premium, you keep the right to remain, and you have to register that choice by the date printed on your Offer Form. Register nothing and Citizens assigns the policy to the takeout company with the lowest estimated premium [2].

The timing is published in advance. On Citizens' 2026 personal lines depopulation calendar, the Policyholder Choice letter goes out roughly seven weeks before the assumption date, and the choice deadline falls about 11 to 12 days before it [3]. Everything below is about how to use that window.

What depopulation is and why Citizens runs it

Citizens Property Insurance Corporation is a not for profit, tax exempt government entity created by the Florida Legislature under s. 627.351(6), Florida Statutes. It is a residual market insurer, built to write risks that cannot obtain coverage in the private market rather than to compete for them. When Citizens grows, so does the state's catastrophe exposure and the pool of Florida policyholders who can be assessed after a bad storm year.

Depopulation is the mechanism the statute gives Citizens to shrink. Private carriers apply to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation for approval to assume blocks of Citizens policies, and OIR issues that approval as a consent order [3]. Approved takeout companies then select the policies they want, and Citizens administers every official communication to the policyholder and the agent of record.

The scale explains why this shows up so often in Miami files now. Citizens reported 1,407,805 policies in force at the end of September 2023 and 278,246 as of June 30, 2026 [4].

How the assumption process works

If one or more approved carriers select your policy, Citizens mails a Depopulation Packet listing every available assumption offer with its estimated renewal premium, alongside the estimated renewal premium for the next term of your Citizens policy, plus coverage worksheets for each option [2].

The published calendar gives the sequence real dates. For the December 15, 2026 assumption, OIR approval was dated September 15, 2026, the Policyholder Choice letter was scheduled for October 28, 2026, and the choice deadline is December 4, 2026 [3]. That is roughly 37 days between the letter and the deadline, and 11 days between the deadline and the assumption.

On the assumption date, Citizens mails a Notice of Assumption and Nonrenewal and a Certificate of Assumption to policyholders whose policies were assumed, and an Unsuccessful Assumption Notice to those whose policies were not [3]. Assumptions do fall through, and if yours does, the policy stays with Citizens and remains eligible for future offers [2].

The eligibility rule and where it lives in the statute

The threshold is statutory, not discretionary. For personal lines residential risks that are primary residences, s. 627.351(6)(c)5.a. provides that for policies renewing on or after April 1, 2023, the risk is not eligible for Citizens coverage unless the private premium is more than 20 percent greater than the Citizens renewal premium for comparable coverage [1]. A parallel provision at s. 627.351(6)(c)5.b. applies the same 20 percent figure to risks that are not primary residences, for policies renewing on or after July 1, 2024 [1].

For takeout offers specifically, s. 627.351(6)(ii)3. provides that a policyholder who receives a take-out offer from an authorized insurer is no longer eligible for Citizens coverage unless the offer is more than 20 percent greater than the Citizens renewal premium. That subparagraph applies to take-out applications submitted to OIR on or after January 1, 2023, and only to policies covering a primary residence [1]. Citizens states the same rule and traces it to Senate Bill 2-A from December 2022 [2].

One detail gets missed: the comparison runs against Citizens' estimated renewal premium, not the premium you pay today.

Opting out, and what the deadline actually does

If you are eligible to remain, the choice must be registered by the date on the Offer Form, either by your agent or online with your policy number and the registration code from the form [2]. Eligible policyholders who elect to stay receive a Remain with Citizens Confirmation Notice [3].

Three details belong on the calendar. A policy with no registered choice is assigned to the takeout company with the lowest estimated premium regardless of eligibility [2]. There is no longer a 30 day post assumption period during which a policyholder can return to Citizens, so once assumption occurs the transfer is final [2]. And electing to stay is not permanent status: you may receive additional offers and must respond to each one, because Florida law requires continued validation of Citizens eligibility through renewal remarketing [2].

How to evaluate a takeout carrier

Treat the offer the way you would treat any other counterparty, and verify the following with your licensed insurance agent rather than from the offer letter alone.

Rating, surplus, and claims record

Ask for the carrier's current financial strength rating and who issued it. Many Florida specialty carriers are rated by Demotech rather than AM Best, and the two scales are not interchangeable. Beyond the letter grade, ask about policyholder surplus, the reinsurance program behind hurricane season, and how long the company has written in South Florida. Claims handling after a named storm tells you more than price, and OIR publishes filings and complaint data.

Coverage, not just premium

Citizens provides coverage worksheets for every offer for exactly this reason [2]. Compare hurricane deductible, water damage sublimits, roof settlement terms, ordinance or law coverage, loss of use, and managed repair provisions. A takeout premium that reads lower can still be the worse contract.

Whether the lender will accept it

For a financed property, the carrier has to clear the investor's rating floor. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide B7-3-01 accepts a carrier rated B or better by AM Best, A or better by Demotech, BBB or better by Kroll, or BBB or better by S&P Global, and a carrier only has to meet one agency's threshold [5]. The same guide allows policies from state or territory insurance plans, including FAIR plans and state mandated windstorm pools, when that is the only coverage obtainable at closing or renewal [5]. Confirm acceptance with the servicer before the assumption date, not after.

When depopulation lands mid transaction

The awkward case is a buyer binding coverage at closing on a home whose seller is mid depopulation cycle. A buyer generally cannot inherit the seller's Citizens policy, so the buyer is a new applicant facing the eligibility test under s. 627.351(6)(c)5. against private offers [1]. If the seller's policy has already been assumed, it remains on Citizens forms through the end of the term, which changes what the existing declarations page tells you [1]. And if the assumption date falls between contract and closing, the carrier and the mortgagee clause can change while the file is open.

The fix is unglamorous: pull the insurance quote before the inspection period closes, and confirm the carrier's rating and lender acceptance in the same pass. On coastal and wind exposed inventory, including much of Key Biscayne, the insurance line is a material part of carrying cost. A buyer consultation is the place to model that before you are negotiating repairs.

Assessments and the residual market lens

If a storm year exceeds Citizens' resources, Florida law lets it recover the deficit through assessments. Citizens describes a policyholder surcharge of up to 15 percent applied to its own policyholders first, followed if needed by an emergency assessment of up to 10 percent per year levied on most Florida property and casualty policies, Citizens and non Citizens alike, for as many years as necessary to eliminate the deficit [6]. On a $3,000 Citizens premium, Citizens illustrates the surcharge alone as roughly $450 [6].

That is the underwriting argument for reading a takeout offer on its merits rather than reflexively opting out. A private policy sits outside the surcharge layer, though it remains exposed to the emergency assessment layer. Whether that trade favors you depends on the specific premium, forms, and carrier, which is a conversation for your licensed agent. If you are weighing whether to hold or sell, the insurance line belongs in the model alongside taxes and association dues, and a listing valuation that ignores carrying cost is not a valuation.

Frequently asked questions

Can I refuse a takeout offer and stay with Citizens?

Only if you remain eligible. If any offer comes in at a premium that is not more than 20 percent greater than Citizens' estimated renewal premium, the option to remain is not available at any point in the process [1][2]. If every offer exceeds that threshold, you may elect to stay by registering your choice by the deadline on the Offer Form [2].

What happens if I miss the deadline?

Citizens assigns the policy to the takeout company that offered the lowest estimated premium, regardless of whether you were eligible to remain [2][3].

Can I go back to Citizens after an assumption?

There is no longer a 30 day post assumption window to return, and once an assumption occurs the transfer is final [2]. Returning means applying for a new Citizens policy and meeting current eligibility and underwriting requirements, including the same 20 percent test against any private offer [1].

Does the assumption change my policy forms mid term?

The statute provides that a policy removed from Citizens through an assumption agreement remains on Citizens policy forms through the end of the policy term [1]. The carrier changes before the forms do. Confirm the specifics on your own declarations page with your agent.

Gabriel

Sources

[Fla. Stat. s. 627.351, Insurance risk apportionment plans (2025) [1]](https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2025/627.351)
[Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, Personal Lines Depopulation [2]](https://www.citizensfla.com/depoppl)
[Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, 2026 Personal Lines Depopulation Calendar (Agent) [3]](https://www.citizensfla.com/documents/20702/107636/2026+Personal+Lines+Calendar_Agent.pdf/bcfde5f2-5171-a05a-e6b6-3e22be318012)
[Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, Policies in Force [4]](https://www.citizensfla.com/policies-in-force)
[Fannie Mae Selling Guide B7-3-01, General Property Insurance Requirements for All Property Types [5]](https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b7-3-01/general-property-insurance-requirements-all-property-types)
[Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, Assessments [6]](https://www.citizensfla.com/assessments)
Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, Depopulation Resources

---

Gabriel A. Moyers, PA. eXp Realty. Florida License #3407280. Equal Housing Opportunity. This article is general information as of July 2026 and is not legal, tax, or financial advice. Verify current figures against authoritative sources before acting.